Machete Cards

Sell Your Cards

Tell Us What You've Got.

Share a few details and photos below. We'll review your collection and reach out through your preferred contact method to talk through your options — a direct offer, consignment, or an honest “hold onto these.”

What we buy

Bulk to graded — it all counts

Pokémon is our deepest specialty, and we evaluate sports cards across eras. If it's cards, we want to see it.

Raw cards

Singles, binders, and boxes — from modern hits to vintage staples.

Graded cards

Slabs from the major grading companies, any grade.

Sealed product

Booster boxes, ETBs, wax, and factory-sealed sets.

Complete sets

Finished and near-complete sets, vintage or modern.

Bulk

Yes, even the giant box of commons. Everything gets a fair look.

Offer math

How offers are calculated

Every offer starts with market value: what cards like yours have actually sold for recently — not sticker prices, not price-guide wishes.

From there we work out expected net recovery: what we realistically expect to collect after selling costs like marketplace fees, shipping, grading where it makes sense, and the time cards sit before they sell. Our offer is a share of that number that leaves room for us to run a real business — and we'll walk you through the reasoning on any card you ask about.

That's also why highly liquid cards get stronger offers than slow movers, and why sometimes the honest answer is “consign this one instead” or “you're better off keeping it.”

Two ways to connect

Local or mail-in

Local appointment

Meet us in person

Within roughly 20 miles of Port Jefferson, NY or Ponte Vedra, FL — and wider when we're on the road for shows. We review your cards together and talk through the numbers face to face.

Mail-in

Ship from anywhere

Not nearby? Submit your details first — if it's a fit, we'll walk you through packing and shipping step by step before anything gets mailed. We'll confirm the process details when we talk.

Start here

Seller intake

Four quick steps. Your progress stays put even if a photo upload hiccups.

  1. 1Contact
  2. 2Collection
  3. 3Photos
  4. 4Review

Contact

Preferred contact method
How would you like to connect?

Questions about safety, authenticity, privacy, or payment? See the FAQ.